FlakMagnet
Well-Known Member
here's my US-made Chippewa rough out service boots. I've had these since 2016, and have only had them resoled once since. They were a bitch to break in as the leather was so stiff, but it was worth it though.
-
When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Boots / shoes to wear with your flight jacket s...
- Thread starter ties70
- Start date
Chandler
Well-Known Member
I have enough boots to spread out over a week's wearing, these days.
I liked the looks of some of Thursday's boots, but they came out with the newer moc-toe right after I'd found a pair I really like (see previous posts).
B-Man2
Well-Known Member
I have a couple of pairs of Thursdays and the only thing I really don’t like is that they don’t gusset the boot tongue to the inside of the lace up area. As a result the tongue often slides left or right and you end up with the laces on your leg and the tongue off to one side of the bootI have enough boots to spread out over a week's wearing, these days.
I liked the looks of some of Thursday's boots, but they came out with the newer moc-toe right after I'd found a pair I really like (see previous posts).
Chandler
Well-Known Member
I've read and heard this complaint before. I'm surprised they haven't addressed it -- they seem to be making changes all the time.
A couple years ago I requested they make their moc-toe style in a smooth, brown leather. They finally introduced it a couple months ago, but they made it with a big, chunky sole.
Didn't grab me at that point.
FlakMagnet
Well-Known Member
The original Thursday Diplomats looked very identical to the Alden Indys. I'm not entirely sure why they've decided to completely overhaul the design. Here's what it looked like: https://www.heddels.com/2014/10/thursday-boot-co-diplomat-boot-review/I've read and heard this complaint before. I'm surprised they haven't addressed it -- they seem to be making changes all the time.
A couple years ago I requested they make their moc-toe style in a smooth, brown leather. They finally introduced it a couple months ago, but they made it with a big, chunky sole.
FlakMagnet
Well-Known Member
I have a couple of pairs as well, but I've never had this problem. To be fair, this is one of the most common complaints about it on the goodyearwelted thread on reddit.
Chandler
Well-Known Member
Wow, I never saw that version -- I'd have bought a pair if they had a darker brown.
Yeah, I wonder why they changed them?
Dumpster D
Well-Known Member
Anyone know a current reproduction of an approximated pair of these?
I had a hard time finding something that wasn't out of production or 'boutique' price.
I had a hard time finding something that wasn't out of production or 'boutique' price.
CombatWombat
Well-Known Member
I'm pretty sure I've seen a Chuck Taylor 75 series in this colourway
jack31916
Well-Known Member
Just google Olive Drab Canvas Shoes or Olive Drab Canvas Sneakers and you will find a pair that fits your feet and wallet
These are looking similar and not too expensive.
northerncobbler.com
These are looking similar and not too expensive.
USR High Khaki | Men's canvas sneaker (vegan friendly)
We have teamed up with the US Rubber Company to bring on board some canvas, vegan-friendly sneakers for the summer months ahead. US Rubber Company started out life providing footwear to the U.S. army. Now manufactured in one of the oldest rubber factories in the world, who have a specific...
Chandler
Well-Known Member
I admit it, I probably take better care of my boots than my jackets -- but they have still developed patina.
But yes, I REALLY find boots more comfortable than sneakers -- probably because they support my flat feet and weak ankles (and thereby my back) better. I pulled out the Danner Explorers for tundra trudging and really forgot how good they feel.
Unlike Nick, however, I don't have a collection that doesn't allow a good rotation. Jackets have reached that quantity, too.
But yes, I REALLY find boots more comfortable than sneakers -- probably because they support my flat feet and weak ankles (and thereby my back) better. I pulled out the Danner Explorers for tundra trudging and really forgot how good they feel.
Unlike Nick, however, I don't have a collection that doesn't allow a good rotation. Jackets have reached that quantity, too.
stephen210
Well-Known Member
what size did you get? If I wear a size 8.5UK do I need a 7.5?
mulceber
Moderator
Here’s my contribution to the thread. For a while now, I’ve been thinking about trying a nice pair of boots, but I fence-sat for a while. While all the ones I’ve seen looked great, I’ve frankly never had a pair of boots that I considered particularly comfortable (and I’ve owned a pair of Alden Indy boots!) I love the idea of “heritage boots,” but I’d never had the experience of owning boots that I ENJOY wearing.
Nevertheless, because of the fine folks here and, even more, because of the boot community on youTube (especially “Rose Anvil,” “Bootlosophy,” “Stridewise,” and “Carl Murawski”), I was feeling the itch (no, it wasn’t athlete’s foot).
What I was looking for:
- Great arch support. That’s apparently not very common with boots, but my doctor has told me I need it, and I wear inserts in most of my shoes. This is probably why Alden was a flop for me. I really wanted a pair of boots that wouldn’t require inserts.
- A streamlined look. I know that the bulbous toe of Iron Rangers is the way boots actually looked back in the day, but I don’t care about accuracy when it comes to boots. I’ve never really liked the rounded toe that you see on actual old-school boots, so Iron Rangers were a no-go.
- Preferably made in the USA, but at least made in a first-world nation. Where possible these days, I like to support our home-grown industries.
More importantly, at least for me, both Nicks and White’s are famous for having great arch support. These two makers are a bit on the expensive side, ranging from $500-700, but I really liked the look of them, and I’ve already had the experience (with jackets) of buying the budget option when you want the deluxe option, and having it not really scratch the itch. So I figured, “what the heck - get the boot you want the first time.” Besides, I’ve had good luck buying my leather jackets from the state of Washington.
So that effectively narrowed my search down to White’s MP service boot, and Nicks’ Americana. The Nicks were cheaper, but they had a longer wait time and the pictures made them look like they had that bulbous toe I don’t like. White’s seemed like exactly what I was looking for. Even better, they frequently have sales that will bring the cost of their service boot down to the same ballpark as Nicks.
I heard good things about their cinnamon waxed flesh (basically a Horween rough-out that’s been so packed with waxes and oils that the rough-out starts to resemble the surface of regular leather), and it looked great to me, so I went for that. After a bit of angsting over the size (tbh, I’m still not sure what my Brannock size is), I bought a pair in 11D in November and sat down for what I expected would be a wait of 2-4 months. Nope! They arrived in just about 4 weeks.
First Impressions:
- They smell fantastic. Stridewise had quipped that his MPs smell like a candle. That makes me think of Yankee Candle. I just think they smell intensely of LEATHER.
- White’s includes two pairs of laces - one pair of leather, and one pair of waxed cotton laces. I picked the waxed cotton, since I thought they’d be more versatile, and let me say, they are SERIOUSLY waxed. The first couple times I laced them up, they were shedding residue. That isn’t a complaint! I just took it as a sign that White’s isn’t messing around.
- The arch support is excellent. For this reason alone, I’d buy PNW again.
- The fit was great - I think it could stand to be a LITTLE more snug. I’ve heard some boot people recommend going a half size smaller and a size wider than White’s size guide recommends. I could probably have done that, but this is a good fit. And it’s got just enough room for me to wear a second pair of socks for breaking in, and for cold days. They advised me well.
- The cinnamon waxed flesh is darker than it looked on my computer screen. I was expecting what we would call a light seal brown, and instead it’s a dark seal. Oh well, no big deal. It’s also a bit less versatile than I expected. I definitely wouldn’t wear these in even a semi-formal setting. Jeans, chinos, and HBT, that’s pretty much all I would wear these with. That said, they look pretty awesome with all of the above.
I started out wearing them a couple hours a day, with a second layer of socks, and worked my way up. I’m now at the point where I can wear them all day with a single layer of trail socks. These are my longer-term thoughts:
- I’m told the waxed rough-out is easier to break in. When I got them out of the box, they were already pretty stiff. I’d HATE to imagine trying to break in a pair of their boots in Chromexcel. I think I made the right call going with waxed flesh.
- One downside of the cinnamon waxed flesh is the tongue: the process of the laces rubbing against the tongue as the boot flexes causes the waxy layer on the tongue to be removed very quickly, resulting in the tongue looking all kinds of chewed up, even though it’s structurally fine. This doesn’t damage the boots, and it isn’t really noticeable when you’re wearing them, so it isn’t a big deal, but I do somewhat wish that they had made the tongue out of a regular leather so it wouldn’t look so chewed up.
- They are very supportive, and pretty comfortable, but not in the way a pair of sneakers are, where it feels like you’re walking on a cloud. Instead, it feels like each part of my foot is getting the support it needs. I still don’t think I’ve broken them in yet, but they’re well on their way and getting a bit better each time.
Last edited:
