• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Throwing My Hats in the Ring

Shanghai-Mayne

Well-Known Member
That makes me feel less crazy. ;)
IMG_5268.jpeg
 

CK90

Well-Known Member

mulceber

Moderator

Initial Impressions​

Before I start fading these hats (that’s several months off at this point anyway), I’m going to share my initial impressions of the hats. I’m going to avoid dwelling on accuracy, partly because not everyone is going to care about stitch-for-stitch accuracy, and an inaccurate hat might very well have qualities that someone here might prize. But mostly I’m side-stepping the accuracy issue because I’ve never owned an original and know fu…err…muck all about them.

To avoid stumbling over the names, one of which is long enough to be annoying, for now I’m going to call them Bravo (Bronson), Mike (MASH), and Whiskey (World War II Impressions).

Left to Right: Mike, Bravo, Whiskey
IMG_3559.png

IMG_3561.png


Color & Material​

A picture’s worth a thousand words, but I’ll add a few. Mike is very much the middle of the pack here, and its shade of Olive drab has a bit of a blue hue to it. Bravo is much more of a yellow cast, while the color of Whiskey reminds me a bit of the sage green used in L-2B flight jackets.

The AAF stamp on Bravo is crisp and black, and it looks like it might have been screen-printed, while the stamps on the other two are a dark blue. Whiskey is quite faded, but both of them genuinely look like they were stamped on.
Screen Shot 2025-02-11 at 9.53.10 PM.png


The material of the three hats all feels the same, and I doubt there’s anyone who could tell the difference between them blindfolded. I did notice as I was looking at them that the weave of the herringbone on Bravo is slightly wider than the other two, but that’s a millimeter’s difference. I don’t care; others might.

I weighed all three on the kitchen scale and got the following numbers:

Bravo: 2.4 oz or 67g
Mike: 2.8 oz or 80g
Whiskey: 2.7 oz or 73g

Label​

Here Whiskey is the outlier. While the other two have an imitation spec. label, Whiskey has a modern-day brand label and a Made in the USA (or as Weston at Rose Anvil says, “mitusa”) label.
Screen Shot 2025-02-11 at 9.55.43 PM.png


Pattern & Construction​

Mike and Whiskey are mostly identical here. On Whiskey, the two front panels bulge outward, giving it a LITTLE BIT of a trucker hat look. That’s just my impression from the first try-on though, and it might be due to how it was packaged.

The major outlier here is Bravo. The bill is narrower, side-to-side, than the other two are:
IMG_3563.png

IMG_3564.png


Also, whereas the other two have some sort of material in the bill to stiffen it, Bravo is completely unstructured.
Screen Shot 2025-02-11 at 9.51.09 PM.png

This isn’t a bad thing, per se, although not everyone may feel that way. I used to wear a newsboy cap with my leather jackets, and an unstructured bill was much more comfortable. I’d frequently forget it was on my head. But the unstructured bill does make me wonder how much starch Bronson had to put into this hat their model wore:

AD_4nXdpEuIrVt3JycAd2EveR_anEZY-3YFUnnYhUFUJaw722f3rmCv364T6zfxweBkx4HbWvI5MrP_8uGOTYHBFs1OGbvvJVka-fhfbYVZLTm5S3jpjgIf7CsU2e81Mv_JtSORbIAcQ

No way they got it to stay that way just from working the brim.

The stitch count on Bravo looks a little lower than the other two. As before, not a big deal to me, but it might be to others.
Screen Shot 2025-02-11 at 9.58.07 PM.png


Sizing​

My head measures 59.5 cm. Ordinarily I wear a 7½, although I occasionally can squeak by on 7⅜. Mike and Whiskey run true to size. For Bravo I had to order a size up, 7¾. All three hats fit basically the same.

Summing Up​

Everything I’ve seen so far leads me to think @Grant was right – I like MASH the best. But we’ll see how they take the heat…starting in about 4 months.
 
Top