A2 vs G-1 - Whats the more comfortable/practical jacket?

[B-Man2]

Makes me think of James Spader's G-1 in Tuff Turf. Was another iconic flight jacket influencer for me...
View attachment 36627
View attachment 36628
View attachment 36629

Hi Bretta
Looking at your photos I’m wondering if his jacket is a G-1 or an AN-J3 as it looks to have a leather collar not a mouton one. What do you think?

 

[MikeyB-17]

It’s not a G-1, definitely a leather collar, although it has a short windflap. Looks like a snap at the bottom of the zip. I suspect Avirex may have had a hand in it.

 

[Brettafett]

Its an original G-1 that had the mouton removed and a leather collar replaced. Custom work. There are a few of these around.
I went on an exercise years ago about this...

 

[MikeyB-17]

Yeah you’re right-just found this which shows the throat latch.

 

[Brettafett]

I was obsessed with this jacket a few years back. Was keen to pick up an original and replicate it

 

[B-Man2]

I was obsessed with this jacket a few years back. Was keen to pick up an original and replicate it

Bretta
I like it ... as I said earlier reminds me of an AN-J-3, but you can certainly find a used g-1 with a messed up collar and restore it to look like this one for reasonable money . The nice thing is we have the people here who could make the collar transfer in a blink.
( You’re thinking about it now ..
.. aren’t you?)

 

[Brettafett]

Darn! Thanks guys.... Yes.... funny thing is... I was on greedy earlier perusing original G-1s!

 

[B-Man2]

Darn! Thanks guys.... Yes.... funny thing is... I was on greedy earlier perusing original G-1s!

Good for you!!
If it becomes a reality you’ve got to show us because I think you’ve started something here.

 

[airfrogusmc]

think a lot of my reasoning is tied to the branch of the Armed Forces that used the jacket. Only ever had one G-1.

Either you're a soldier, or a sailor.

Or a Marine.

 

[MikeyB-17]

I was obsessed with this jacket a few years back. Was keen to pick up an original and replicate it

92nd fighter group patch?

 

[Brettafett]

It would appear so, but as this is a 'movie' jacket, ie one can't really tell how far it was messed with for the production. It appears all original... It had a chit on the back also.

 

[MikeyB-17]

Whoever did it did a good job to the collar. I've often fancied an AN-J-3, but always found the collar a bit too 70's.

 

[Brettafett]

Totally agree.
I need up getting an unpatched Cockpit Forrestal G-1, hoping to get something akin to this. The Cockpit G-1s (especially the 100 missions) are very nice, albeit overpriced...
Anyway, the Forrestal leather collar imo was not very nice in person. Returned it.
Need a cheap as chips decent 60s or 70s G-1 and then match the goat as best as possible and fit.

 

[London Cabbie]

I have a ELC G1.

I love it.

However because of this forum I have purchased my first A2, Seal Dubow from Platon. The A2 fits me perfect and is a little more restrictive than the G1, which are both size 42. The G1 size is a tiny bit larger in size and less restrictive due to the Bi-Swing back. Also the goatskin has softened after wearing it regularly for a few months recently (did not wear it for over 13 years from purchase...)
The A2 horsehide feels stiffer but is only six months old.
I can throw on the G1 and not worry about it. The A2 needs a little bit of adjusting when wearing a sweatshirt underneath, but when it’s on it fits like a glove, I wear it round the house often because I love it so much.
I like the G1 in colder weather and that suits the mouton collar, if I dropped a size maybe I would wear it a little more.
The A2 goes with EVERYTHING and because it is sort of simpler in design it looks less fussy. I have another A2 on order, what can I say...

 

[B-Man2]

Cabby
Both jackets look great on you......
So.... you have another A2 on order?
Hmmmm..... sounds like you’re addicted now...
Welcome to the club....
Who’s the maker of the A2 on order ?

 

[London Cabbie]

Thanks. Russet Platon Dubow based primarily on price then the fit. You then start to wonder about how the fit and feel of another manufacturer might be if money was no problem.

First world problems...I was warned.

 

[Brettafett]

Great jackets both. And great fit!

 

[rob20uk]

Hi Everyone,

So in the end I decided to buy all the various combinations.

This week I finally after three attempts over the last year to find the right A2 I found one that fits. It’s the Eastman Star contact. It’s perfect in the sleeves and in the body length.

As for the G-1 I ended up getting three. I got the Eastman G-1. Then I followed the advice on the form and picked up a used military issue one from 1996. It was only £70 and is in fantastic condition other than the knits needing replacement. Absolute bargain. I also got the current mill spec cockpit jacket. This fit is a lot more of a regular fit and is just a good everyday casual jacket.

Anyway I thought I would just say thanks for all your help.

Thanks for all your help.

 

[London Cabbie]

Hi Everyone,

So in the end I decided to buy all the various combinations.

This week I finally after three attempts over the last year to find the right A2 I found one that fits. It’s the Eastman Star contact. It’s perfect in the sleeves and in the body length.

As for the G-1 I ended up getting three. I got the Eastman G-1. Then I followed the advice on the form and picked up a used military issue one from 1996. It was only £70 and is in fantastic condition other than the knits needing replacement. Absolute bargain. I also got the current mill spec cockpit jacket. This fit is a lot more of a regular fit and is just a good everyday casual jacket.

Anyway I thought I would just say thanks for all your help.

Thanks for all your help.

Photos, photos, photos NOT (thumbnails) @B-Man2

 

[AlexLutov]

I have a ELC G1.

I love it.

However because of this forum I have purchased my first A2, Seal Dubow from Platon. The A2 fits me perfect and is a little more restrictive than the G1, which are both size 42. The G1 size is a tiny bit larger in size and less restrictive due to the Bi-Swing back. Also the goatskin has softened after wearing it regularly for a few months recently (did not wear it for over 13 years from purchase...)
The A2 horsehide feels stiffer but is only six months old.
I can throw on the G1 and not worry about it. The A2 needs a little bit of adjusting when wearing a sweatshirt underneath, but when it’s on it fits like a glove, I wear it round the house often because I love it so much.
I like the G1 in colder weather and that suits the mouton collar, if I dropped a size maybe I would wear it a little more.
The A2 goes with EVERYTHING and because it is sort of simpler in design it looks less fussy. I have another A2 on order, what can I say...View attachment 36728View attachment 36729

Bro, great fit for both jackets!