Best B-10 repro?

Guys,
In your opinion, who makes the best B-10 repro? I am looking at ELC, or Buzz. I'm looking for a size 46. Thanks.

Seth

I like and have owned both including a Real McCoys Japan model. I like them all and think you could not go wrong with any of them.

If you can find a Real McCoys Japan jacket go with that. The Buzz and ELC jackets are both good choices as well, neither has any major drawbacks in my opinion.

If you have any interest in a WPG size 46 thats new with the tag and never worn. I have one that I would let go for a very reasonable price. You can PM me if your interested.


Regards
B-Man2

I had an 48" AERO B-10 first, which had the typical problem: It featured the typical short body measurements and ended at the top of my belt (though an extra inch was added).

Second came an ELC in 46" which was one of their first production run models...





It was a nice jacket, but ended up on Ebay, because it was really trim.

I then somehow got the feeling that the B-10 pattern was simply not the correct fit for me, and started to look for a jacket from the "cheaper" manufacturers (ATF....). Though their patterns might be off regarding authenticity, I might fit into their stuff....but in the end I didn't want to spent the money on fake alpaca....

Then, finally: I contacted Paddy Curral from RMNZ and asked her about a B-10 from THE FEW collection, as they supplied some jackets for George Lucas' RED TAILS movie....and BINGO!



This is the best B-10 repro for me. If they still have some of these left (and I remember that the jackets were mainly "46, with lots of room (I usually have to get a "50 in RMNZ and a "48 for all other makers), you should try to grab one!!

Ties

Looks nice Ties. The FEW prices scare me though. :?

BTW, I had a ELC B-10 and thought it was a very nice replication, but didn't like the fact I had to wear long sleeves with it. Very itchy. :roll:

Weasel_Loader said:

Looks nice Ties. The FEW prices scare me though. :?

BTW, I had a ELC B-10 and thought it was a very nice replication, but didn't like the fact I had to wear long sleeves with it. Very itchy. :roll:

Click to expand...

I know what you mean re. their prices. As the jacket was an unused film prop, that had been shipped around the globe once, Paddy sold it as a 2nd hand item...the price was very reasonable (750 NZD). That's what you would have to spend on a Buzz B-10 from Historypreservation.com...

If she still has one of these, get it!

Ties

Thanks for all the opinions guys. I'll look into the RMNZ as well as teh Buzz. I think I might stay away from the ELC as I don't care for how their knits hold up, or lack thereof.

I have owned various repro and original B-10s. The most accurate B-10 IMO is the RW version produced by ELC. Mine is around two years old and there are no issues with it. The knits are fine and not flimsy like on some of their recent A2s. The price is also very competitive too.

I agree, the recent ELC RW B-10 is an exceptional reproduction. I've owned original Rough Wear B-10's and it's pretty darn close. As for the itchy alpaca lining, if you've ever worn an original B-10, B-15, B-15a or N-1 you know the alpaca can drive you nuts not wearing long sleeves. The knits on both of my ELC B-10's are holding up quite well.

ELC RW. compared to an original of the same contract, only the newness gives it away

Grant said:

I agree, the recent ELC RW B-10 is an exceptional reproduction. I've owned original Rough Wear B-10's and it's pretty darn close. As for the itchy alpaca lining, if you've ever worn an original B-10, B-15, B-15a or N-1 you know the alpaca can drive you nuts not wearing long sleeves. The knits on both of my ELC B-10's are holding up quite well.

Click to expand...

Well said, and I agree on all mentioned above. ELC RW B-10 is the best in my opinion. I've owned all the others. My originals itch with short sleeves as well but honestly I never wear a B-10 with short sleeves to begin with since it is more of a cold weather jacket.

Have you even seen a real B-10 JK???????????????????????????????

Clark J said:

Have you even seen a real B-10 JK???????????????????????????????

Click to expand...

Maybe.

I've seen many a real B-10, and by what I have read the ELC is the best repop out there. I'll take you guys word on the knits and probably give HPC a call tomorrow or Wednesday.

ELC is certainly lovely and very nice.

I've got a Buzz Rickson Superior Togs B-10 and it's on of my favourite jackets. I really like the rust red knits and the contrast with the rest of the jacket. It's nice to be a bit different.

Cheers

I went ahead and got the Buzz Roughwear from HPA here in the states. It came in today and is a very, very nice jacket. I'll post some pics soon. Thanks guys.